Research Reports
□ Research Background and Purpose
For the last fifteen years, regional industrial policy has changed in terms of its goals, methods and supporting systems. Along with the changes in regime, the regional industrial goals have also transformed from ‘promoting the regional economy’ to ‘balancing national development’, ‘strengthening regional competitiveness’, and ‘improving residents’quality of life’. The focus of regional industrial policy has also shifted from promoting province-level strategic industries to mega-city level leading industries, and then to province-level major industries. Recently, the number of strategic industries has been expanded from one to a maximum of eight per province. However, in order to increase productive outcomes of regional industrial policy, maintaining consistency between goals, approaches and means is crucial. To achieve such consistency, the theoretical basis of regional industrial policy should be strengthened.
There are three major problems to be considered in developing regional industrial policy in Korea as follows. First of all, policy goals should be clearly defined, in order to maintain consistency. Secondly, severe disparities between the initial goals and actual performance of regional industry policy should be resolved. For example, the central government often intervenes with the regional government’s initiated program through providing the guidelines. Third, strategies and means of regional industrial policy must be oriented towards achievement of fundamental goals. Regards to this issue, it is noticeable that industrial clustering strategy does not largely affect the balanced national development. A cluster is originally accompanied with geographic concentration of industries, and thus it may rather deepen regional disparity. Promoting innovation to balance national growth is another example of unsuitability, deviating from achieving competitiveness or productivity of lagged regions. This is because such regions usually lack absorptive ability and innovative capability to realize such innovation. Furthermore, selection and concentration on a strategic industry also seems inappropriate, because it may cause even greater disparity among industries in the region.
Thus, this research aims to achieve the following five purposes.
First, it examines the current issues of regional industrial policy; second, the issues are theoretically analyzed in-depth; third, contributions and limitations of regional industrial policy are defined; fourth, the ways to improve regional industrial policy are suggested; and finally, directions for better performance of regional industrial policy in the future are recommended.
□ Research Results
We determined the key issues of regional industrial policy to be the following. First, we examined regional industrial theories and their trends and reviewed the recent issues to clarify its concepts, scopes, rationales, purposes, strategies, entities and means. Accordingly, regional industrial policy is defined as “an intentional intervention of the government or the public sector to maintain and develop local business and industry.” Regional industrial policy includes both regional policy and industrial policy. This research approaches a region and industry at a meso-level and identifies them as relatively independent areas. Based on the above definition and approaches, we insist that a regional government initiated program with support from the central government is more suitable for achieving policy goals.
Second, we analyze the Korean regional industrial policy in terms of its goals, strategies, subjects and means.
Third, the cases of regional industrial policies of the EU, the United Kingdom, France and Japan are investigated. The case of the EU regional policy clearly shows a bottom-up approach. The UK implements an integrated policy at the central government level and emphasizes public private partnership (PPP). In France, the central government, especially DATAR, plays an important role in regional industrial policy. Japan has shifted its policy focus from balanced development to revitalization of its regional economy, and has adopted an endogenous development strategy.
Fourth, a survey of experts in this field was conducted. According to the survey, which addressed the goals of regional industrial policy, strengthening the region’s industrial competitiveness (received 8.8 out of 10) was regarded more important than balanced regional development (7.5). Also, a regional government-led bottom-up approach (7.9) was found to be more appropriate than a central government-led top-bottom approach (6.1). The survey also showed that an endogenous development strategy (8.3) is more important than an exogenous development one (7.2).
Fifth, the regression equation was estimated to identify regional industrial policy goals by using Korean data. It appears that when gross regional domestic product (GRDP) per capita increases, regional economic disparity (coefficient of variation) also increases. This shows that economic efficiency and regional disparity mitigation have a trade-off relationship. Hence, this study suggests that regional industrial policy goals should focus on strengthening the regional industries’competitiveness and efficiency.
Sixth, industry targeting, cluster formation and endogenous development methods have been examined as possible strategies for regional industrial policies. In a selective industry system, although it is appropriate for the central government to have a functional approach in all regions, it is job of regional governments to select and support the particular industries for their regions. For a successful cluster strategy, connections among corporations are very important. Therefore, an agglomeration of corporations is needed more than branch plants. As Korea’s economy evolves into an innovation-driven economy, the conversion from an exogenous development strategy focusing on attracting business & public investment to an endogenous development strategy, in which regional resources and potentials may be optimized, is necessary.
Seventh, the role of the central and local governments in regional industrial policy is analyzed. The local government takes a leading role in regional industrial policies while the central government takes a supportive role. The regional government designs and executes detailed plans and promotes interaction among economic entities. On the other hand, the central government acts as a coordinator and facilitator to help the regional government implement policies. More specifically, the central government constructs related institutional systems, provides administrative and financial aid, supports local capacity improvements and creates a spillover effect to other regions.
Eighth, for regional industrial policy means, revitalization of platform functions that enhance the externality of industrial clusters is necessary. Broker systems should be enhanced to facilitate network. Programs that strengthen policy making and execution capacity should be developed and supported. There should be a conversion from the existing cost-subsidy system to an investment supporting system. And a support system that promotes public-private partnership should be developed.
□ Direction of Policy Improvement
First, it is necessary to set a clear policy goal and present an intermediate objective for its evaluation. The main goal of regional industrial policies is to improve competitiveness by enhancing the productivity of local industries.
Second, growth potentials and opportunities of all regions should be utilized to their full potential. The national capital area plays the role of a pioneer of regional development with global functions. Central provincial cities serve as incubation base for innovation and supply business services. Small and medium size cities take the role of specializing in competitive fields and serve as bases for growth.
Third, each region should specialize in its comparative advantage. Each region needs to specialize and foster the industry that best suits its conditions. The central government should support every necessity that occurs in fostering regional industries and also help the regional government establish and implement their regional industrial policies.
Fourth, it is necessary to switch strategies from trying to attract companies of other regions to creating innovation through active interaction among enterprises. The focus of cluster formations needs to be converted from a passive approach of simply reducing costs to an active approach of creating value.
Fifth, sustainable growth should be promoted through an endogenous development strategy. As Korea’s economy transforms from an investment-driven economy to an innovation-driven economy, it is necessary to break away from development strategies of attracting external companies or public investments, and shift to an endogenous development strategy. Such a strategy will help to ease the financial burden of the central government in times of low growth rates.
Sixth, the regional government should secure regional autonomy, as the local government has more abundant information about regional characteristics and conditions that enable them to establish more fitting policies.
Seventh, policies that enhance the self-sustainability of a region should be supported. The central government-led regional industrial policy should be changed into a regional government-led one. In addition, the following three conditions must be fulfilled in order for the local government to successfully lead its regional industrial policy: ensured local devolution, expansion of financial independence and increased local government capacity of policy planning and implementation. Also, it is crucial to create public private partnerships (PPP) to attract private participation.
The works on this page are licensed for fair use under the provisions of the Korea Open Government License. See kogl.or.kr for more information.
Please enter the security text below
to prevent email collection
Please check the information of the person in charge.
연구과제 제안이 접수되었습니다.
신청이 접수되었습니다.
View Summary
코로나19 발생 이후 대부분의 고용 관심사가 항공 및 여행서비스, 음식·숙박 서비스 등 주로 서비스 업종에 집중된 상황에서 본 연구는 최근 그 중요성이 강조되고 있는 제조업의 고용변화를 살펴보았다. 분석에 따르면, 코로나19 이후 제조업 고용은 비교적 큰 충격 없이 빠르게 회복하는 모습을 보이고 있다. 제조업 고용은 서비스업에 비해 큰 충격 없이 유지되고 있고, 코로나19 직후 2020년 상반기에 약간 하락하였지만 하반기부터 회복 추세를 보이고 있으며, OECD 주요국의 제조업과 비교하여도 일본과 함께 고용 충격이 비교적 작게 나타나고 있다. 그러나 전반적으로 양호한 고용 성적에도 불구하고 제조업 내 특성 별로는 차이가 나타나는 것으로 보인다. 종사상 지위 별로 보면, 임시·일용직, 고용원이 있는 자영업자에서 고용 충격이 상대적으로 크게 나타났고, 상용직과 고용원이 없는 자영업자는 큰 충격이 없는 것으로 나타났다. 제조업 규모별로는 300인 이상의 경우 코로나 발생 초기 약간의 충격 이후 고용이 빠르게 반등하면서 코로나 이전보다 고용이 더 증가한 반면, 이보다 작은 규모의 제조업체들의 경우 고용 회복이 더디게 나타나고 있다. 고용의 중장기, 단기 추세선을 비교한 결과 제조업 업종에 따른 차이를 보였다. 코로나 발생 이전 3년간의 추세선을 2020년 1월부터 연장한 선과, 2020년 1월부터의 실제 자료를 이용한 단기 추세선을 비교한 결과, 의약품은 코로나19 발생 이전부터 시작하여 코로나19 발생 이후에도 견조한 증가세를 유지하고 있으며, 전자부품·컴퓨터, 기타운송장비, 가구는 코로나19 이후 오히려 고용 추세가 개선되었다. 그러나 다수 업종은 코로나 발생 이후 고용이 하락하였는데, 특히, 비금속광물, 1차금속, 금속가공 분야나 인쇄·기록매체 업종에서 하락이 상대적으로 크게 나타났다.
The following information is provided.
inform@kiet.re.krPlease complete the CAPTCHA below.
[전지적키에트시점] (Eng sub)심상치 않은
국내 대기업 움직임??
KIET 시점에서 보는 미래 로봇 산업 전망은
어떨까요?
경제전문가가 알려드립니다!
(산업연구원 박상수 실장)
