In general, regional development policies have been issued in countries having regional disparities such as France, England, Italy, and Japan. These countries have mono-centric development around the Capital areas. Therefore, balanced growth has been set as the objective of regional policies. As the paradigm shifts in regional policies from balanced growth to regional competitiveness, strategic aspects of regional development policies, such as policy tools of enhancing regional industrial development, have started to receive more attention. Balanced growth, however, all the while remains as an important part of the overarching regional policy goal. Korea has followed same steps. After full-fledged autonomy in 1994 in the Civilian government, regional economies have been recognized as independent policy subjects. Thus, four provincial governments requested national funding for developing strategic future industries, which became the origin of the Regional Industrial Promotion Projects (RIPPs) in 1998. The Participatory government established the regional development system with the Special Acts on the Balanced National Development, Special Accounts, and the Presidential Committee as a focal governing instrument. The current government has paid much attention to the efficiency of regional policies and thus set the goal of enhancing regional competitiveness and accelerating decentralization by establishing more block grants for local governments.
Therefore, the purposes of this research are to analyze the performances of regional development policies since 1998, to identify the most appropriate indicators and spatial scopes reflecting current situation, and to suggest policy implications for future through reviewing projects that are significant in terms of its allocated budget.
In total, 21 indicators reflecting regional development have been selected to diagnose the performances of recent regional development policies in the five sectors: Economy, Innovation & Creativity Capacity, SOC, Industry, and Social Issue. In all sectors except Social Issue, the Capital Economic Region shows good performances. The Chungcheng Economic Region has improved its SOC and Industry sectors in late 2000s. In Innovation & Creativity Capacity sector, the Capital Economic Region records highest number of the indicators followed by the Chungcheng Economic Region which comes especially close the first runner in the number of registered patents. In the Social Issue sector, the Capital and Chungcheng Economic Regions have higher rates in divorced and suicide, which might be a side effect of unbalanced economic growth.
Index analysis has been also conducted to review the performances of regional development policies to their purpose. The development disparity index measured by Gini and the coefficient of variation in GRDPs and labor income across regions showed that the regional disparity has been growing constantly and the concentration in the Capital Region has been further intensifying recently. In particular, the disparity measured in average wage across region has increased under the unfavorable external economic environment such as global financial crisis. The centripetal index of each Economic Region measured by the statistical indicators of local hub MSAs compared to that of the Economic Regions shows that the economic activities in local hub MSAs are not improved. Thus, it seems that the performances of regional development policies are not necessarily consistent with the policy goal. The budget allocation in regional projects shows almost uniform distribution across region, even though the government brings the banner of regional competitiveness. Of course, it is also possible that a period as long only as a decade is not enough for the policy performances to be sprawled effectively. Therefore, at the end, this research suggests critical recommendations for the future policy adjustments. As argued and suggested by OECD, integrated policy would be more effective than separated sectoral policy approaches, and it can be realized through mutually active and productive communications among stakeholders in the process of policy making and policy implementation.
There are a couple of contributions of this research to the regional development policy studies. First of all, the labor income from the Occupational Employment Statistic (OES) data in the Korea Employment Information Service as a backup for the Gross Regional Domestic Products (GRDPs) has been used to analyze the regional development, accounting for the fact that the gap exists between GRDPs and living standard. It is the first trial to use the labor wages in the analysis of regional development. Second, social indicators such as the diffusion rate of health insurance, divorce rate, and suicide rate are considered to measure social problem as complementary factors for the products and/or income. As Wilkinson and Pickett (2011) clarified, there is a significant relationship between income disparity and social problems, which reminds policy makers what the ultimate goal of regional policy is. Third, the economic-geographical spatial scopes such as the Metropolitan Statistical Areas (MSAs) and Economic Regions have been used to reduce distortion in interpreting the statistics acknowledging the possibilities of administrative districts failing to grasp the reality in data. For example, the population of Seoul is about 10 million in 2010, while that in Seoul MSA is about 17 million. Fourth, the indices used in this research are created to be consistent with the objectives of the overall regional policy. For example, using the coefficient of variation and Gini index with GRDPs to measure how the economic activities are distributed across regions, the study helps monitoring policy effects on balanced growth. Furthermore, the concentration ratio of the hub MSAs in each Economic Region is quite unique and effective to check the level of regional competitiveness, which is also first trial in the regional development policy studies. Fifth, this research includes budget analysis on some projects under regional industrial policies, which helps to understand the gap between actual policy realization and ideal policy concept. We find that budget allocation is often not consistent with the policy goal in that most of the budgets for regional development projects are uniformly distributed. Lastly, policy implications for supplementing current policies have been suggested. Integrated approach rather than sectoral approach is recommended and the active inter-governmental, inter-ministerial and inter-divisional communications are also recommended.